Close this search box.

Better Technical Education and learning: Distinctiveness of Humanities, Indian English, and ESP

I am grateful to the arranging committee for considering about me and inviting me to supply a visitor lecture on distinctiveness of Humanities and social sciences in larger specialized instruction. I sense relatively uneasy and very septic, as I stand listed here with no pretensions of a high-brow professor or expert whose discourse goes overhead. I speak to you as a training teacher of English language skills, specifically for science and engineering, and Indian English writing, primarily poetry, with fascination in what fears us in the Humanities division, which, regretably, enjoys small educational regard in the more than-all scheme of issues in almost each specialized institution.

Probably, a convention like this augurs properly for good friends in the office of Humanities & Social Sciences, as they look for to check out interdisciplinarity, which in fact expands the scope of training and research. But I will have to present a standpoint to my quite a few remarks that ensue from my reflections on the high-quality of intellectual activity in most technical establishments vis-a-vis the negligible guidance for scholarship in the Humanities, potentially with the belief that the humanities are not ‘real subjects’ or that these have no bearing on discovering of technical topics, or these convey no demonstrable economic advantage.

The discipline has declined more perceptibly with, to quotation Nannerl O. Keohane, “the generation of progressively specialised disciplines and benefits for faculty users for advancing understanding in those people locations.” We have a marginalized position in complex institutions even if we might have been actively playing a crucial purpose as teachers of languages and letters. I do not want to dwell on them right here. But, we should be informed of the ground truth.

Of course, examine in humanities is not often a make a difference of speaking ‘new findings’ or proposing a ‘new theory’. It is instead ‘cultivating understanding’ or pondering critically about some profound queries of human lifestyle it is normally the expression of the deepened comprehending, which some individual has obtained, through studying, dialogue and reflection, on a topic which has been ‘known’ for a extended time. To me, methods in arts and humanities elevate consciousness, refine susceptibilities in numerous directions, produce further awareness, and help us to react critically and independently to the ‘brave new world’ we stay in. Arts and humanities on your own can support us to check out what it usually means to be human, and sustain “the heart and soul of our civilization.” Perhaps, it really is the usefulness of humanities which is acknowledged by inviting me to speak to a distinguished viewers like this.

I intend to divide my quick into two sections: I would reflect on technical establishments as schools of higher studying and then, I would say a little something about the small business of English language educating, which is my key skilled issue. Still, considerably will remain unsaid, for I am mindful of the controversies I might be increasing.

I strongly sense most university degree technical institutions in India, like the general types, have unsuccessful in advertising or upholding wholesome intellectual attitudes and values, and academic lifestyle and custom, envisioned of a university, just as, it’s distressing for me to notice, the society has been pretty much dismal in the circumstance of studies in arts and humanities in the final 4 a long time. The dullness and sameness has marginalized equally artistic and vital functionality, or the criteria handed down to us have grow to be out of date, or we have fallen into an abyss of unbecoming elitism, or we have come to be utilised to a cornucopia of pleasures formerly denied us: I won’t comment. But an chance, these kinds of as this, is necessarily not to provide any authoritative judgments but to mirror on, or to provide insights into, challenges that concern intellectuals at the prime of college teaching hierarchy. Must I say ‘non-university’? for I dread most of the college do not want to move past the parochial confines of slender exclusivity. It truly is the age of specialization they say, and discourage range, tolerance and inclusivity: they do not strive for intellectual mobility and transform of angle we, as seniors, as well, have not tried to achieve out, or investigate!

As a university, we are not oriented to the transformation of our social purchase, nor are we obligated to act as a ethical deterrent in inhibiting the expansion of egocentric motivation. We believe of instruction in terms of laboratory or industrial methods in mineral and mining sectors, vitality, electronics, engineering, pc application, natural environment, administration, legislation, health sciences, existence sciences, and all that, but hardly care for ‘producing’ completely skilled and spiritually mature human beings. We do not spend interest to the growth of specific creativeness and to an intuitive comprehending of specific function. We do not trouble to teach with, to estimate Rabindranath Tagore, the “understanding of religious this means of existence” which is also the ethical and moral which means. We have been, however, bogged down in schemes that inculcate a behavior of the thoughts which indulges in trying to find only superior opportunities to endure, or greater pay back deals.

I am fearful for also lengthy we have practiced the “how to” of lifetime and neglected the “why”. I consider it is comparatively uncomplicated to understand how to execute specific content jobs, but significantly additional difficult to discover “what for”. If our educational procedure has failed about the decades, it is because we have by no means come into a functioning knowledge of our humanity. We have attained amazing total of complex understanding, perhaps a lot more than enough to take care of many challenges with which mankind is presently confronted, but we have hardly ever attempted to reflect on how to implement it constructively and productively for the superior of all, with a perception of human dignity.

Some of us rightly be concerned about the typical lack of mutual respect for the legal rights and emotions of other folks, the tendency to be suspicious of the unfamiliar, the tendency to acquire liberty with the sanctity of the particular person person, and complain about the general deficiency of character and integrity, despite greater education and learning. I see our failure in communicating with the religious perception which is marked by a equilibrium amongst unique dreams and social requires I see our failure in building the recognition of the world of values and principle of the religious oneness underlying the fantastic variety found in the globe. I see our failure in the humanity staying torn aside by intolerance and fundamentalism, the suicidal urge for self-destruction. I see our failure in the climbing ethnic, linguistic and religious tensions that now belie the scientific, technological and enlightened euphoria of the sixties.

We appear to have dropped a sense of obligation towards producing a fantastic, tolerant, forward-seeking society. Many thanks to the position of revenue in democratic processes and institutionalization of corruption at all ranges, individuals have missing faith in politicians, bureaucrats and governing administration. The invasion of governance by the felony-politician-bureaucrat nexus has completed the country greatest harm than the shift of energy pursuing the wave of globalization, multinational capitalism, corporate economic system, politics of war on terror, environmental worries, human legal rights and all that. There is a reshaping of self, values and norms with dominance of the Western discourse in critical reasoning and reflection by way of perils and delights of development and improve by means of survival skills vis-à-vis emigration, sexual intercourse, parenthood, and age by way of re-checking out past and current with vested recognition via political orthodoxy in the title of democracy, religious fanaticism, casteist dominance, and repression of the liberals and the uncomplicated and by the new processes of fossilization of the pre-colonial/colonial/write-up-colonial that renders quite a few of us in the profession irrelevant. I speculate if we are not terribly dislocated in our tiny planet.

Permit me not digress any additional. Females and Gentlemen, each individual university is a school of better education and learning, but how superior is superior? If we are only fascinated in technical training for the sake of creating skilled potential or skill in some space of lifetime, then we are chatting about a vocational faculty or polytechnic, and not a legitimate college. However, most universities (and specialized establishments) have been vying with each individual other to grow to be specialist schools, not dedicated to the training of superior morality, larger philosophy, universal buy or common tradition. They are not developing morally and ethically acutely aware excellent citizens. I am fearful all 1 can hope from the present priorities in the so called better schooling is survival, pursuit of cash, and electricity.

When science is reworked into know-how, it will become a sort of electrical power. And, as history would testify, ability is the ability for good and for evil. The technological tradition we reside in pervades and shapes our lives. The laptop and world-wide-web culture, digital devices, microwave, fridge, cellular phones, antibiotics, contraceptives and numerous such gadgets have been far more than new means. Our perception of vulnerability has been switching rapid. The new consumerist culture has taken absent what was before significant and wealthy encounters of everyday living.

We in the Humanities & Social sciences department will need to discussion the multifaceted truth that fashionable technological innovation gives-not only its units and infrastructure which are its substance manifestation but also skills and business, attitudes and tradition, perhaps constructively and contextually. Imagining by means of technologies really should make doable for us to build and add to humanities philosophy of science and engineering just as different visions might be achievable to discuss as a result of social philosophy of engineering. Scientists in the West have previously been chatting about know-how as liberator, engineering as menace, and technology as instrument of energy. Our life and thoughts have as a result transformed and will continue to modify. In simple fact, just about every area has been altering fast these times. The discipline (HSS) requires to incorporate their research, particularly as media these as internet and social networking have previously modified and redefined human romance and identities everywhere and at all amounts.

Then, there is the emergence of what has been termed ‘knowledge society’. The progress or generation of know-how modern society that we have been chatting about considering the fact that the beginning of this century presupposes our ability for thought era. But if information is not produced freely offered to all who seek out it, how can 1 boost humanity or make it power for a liberal democratic modern society. Additionally, as scientific and complex expertise spreads or will become far more highly effective, it would come to be additional problematic for the scientific group to assume moral accountability for the use and abuse of scientific expertise. To mitigate this challenge, just one needs an instruction not so considerably in science but in humanities. When researchers say they want to are living up to their social tasks, what they look to necessarily mean is that they want more electricity than they have it implies they want to operate things, to take cost. They should not stop up ‘doing politics’ in the title of improving the environment or society. Allow them be fascinated in on their own, in dealing with the activity of their personal self-enhancement, and finding out how to consider about their very own tasks in a much more significant and reflective way, their personal ethical education.

As a college in the Office of Humanities and Social Sciences in one particular of the leading technical universities in the state, what I feel the scientific and engineering neighborhood has to facial area up to is its possess self-education and learning, its individual social schooling. Our budding engineers and researchers have to examine solutions to this kind of primary inquiries as: what is a very good society? How do we go about accomplishing it? How do we-what do we-find out from heritage? What do we understand from political philosophers of the previous? Or, why scientists consider and speak the way they do? They cannot neglect this kind of academic enquiry in complex training since there is far more and a lot more to know as the fields proliferate. Which suggests, the section of Humanities and Social Sciences need to equip them with the basics that can help them reveal understanding in and throughout the important disciplines: scientific comprehending, complex knowledge, mathematical comprehending, historic understanding, creative/humanistic being familiar with, cross-cultural being familiar with, and understanding of ethical and political philosophy, and philosophy of science etc. There is want for supplying new unfamiliar concepts and examples to market these kinds of comprehension which will later help them to consider great conclusions vis-à-vis the complexity of the planet science and engineering has brought about.

With the existing consciousness, take it or not, we, in educational institutions, have perpetuated living with a earth in upheaval, and in some situations, have even proven a choice for it. But, with a bigger order of recognition that ways intuitive ranges of comprehending (a thing arts, tradition and humanistic scientific studies in essence search for to acquire), we should really be much better in a position to search at an concern from several different proportions, and rationalize how we should to are living in the future “as total citizens who can assume for themselves, criticize traditions, and understand the significance of a further person’s sufferings and achievements,” to quotation Martha Nusbaum from her reserve Not for Profit.

A technological college requires to present for education and learning which also elevates the consciousness and extends the electric power of the soul that is, we will need to change a portion of the present-day academic priorities from the intellect to the coronary heart, and from scientific and specialized imagining to soul cognition. The end and purpose of a university, be it specialized or normal, is the perfection of male, striving to evolve the consciousness in tune with the universe.

The education we ‘sell’ requirements to be re-tuned to creative imagination, innovation, and regard for fundamental flexibility our guidelines and curiculums should help in strengthening the culture and values of a world wide society which is characterised by multiculturalism, intercultural interactions, mutual respect, tolerance, dignity and respect for values, and consciousness of ourselves as one human race, human rights and worldwide obligation for transform in attitudes. We should, at each stage, strive for a stability amongst the regular attitudes and the need for a modern day multi-cultural culture.

I consider most of the new technical establishments can preserve their distinctiveness by severely opening to the diversity of our occasions, by sharing freely with learners symbolizing the range of our more substantial culture, culture, and potential desires. The enclave solution which seeks to shut out or at minimum severely limit the assorted socio-cultural requirements and knowing may perhaps not support any extra to keep distinctiveness of the institution.

I also fear about the system’s unwillingness to nurture the ethos and sensibility that sustains a university spirit even as, in accordance to the current govt. procedures, an establishment of bigger mastering is predicted to run as a business enterprise company which in times to come, will modify, perhaps irreversibly, our attitudes to teaching and investigation, our notions of information, our administrative methods, and our romantic relationship with the point out and modern society. We will need to make a go from the issues of the speedy existing to the long run and visualize a different typology of cultural, linguistic and academic challenges against the backdrop of a incredibly fluctuating socio-political local climate and pressures of all varieties.

As part of the language and literature instructing fraternity for about 38 years and operating in a specialised university, I know how substantial Humanities instructing is to hone the mind, important pondering and interaction expertise. I am tempted to quotation Erwin Griswold (of the Harvard Law School): “You go to a fantastic university not so much for knowledge as for arts or behaviors for the artwork of expression, for the artwork of coming into swiftly into a further person’s views, for the artwork of assuming at a moment’s detect a new intellectual position, for the habit of submitting to censure and refutation, for the art of indicating assent or dissent in graduated terms, for the practice of pertaining to minute details of accuracy, for the artwork of doing the job out what is attainable in a given time for flavor, for discrimination, for mental braveness, and mental soberness.”

Now, allow me talk about the business of English Language Instructing. I say ‘business’ due to the fact it has developed into a multi-million pounds commercial business outside the house the indigenous bases. We far too, have an opportunity to capitalize on it in our very own way, if we can. We can arrive at out to people in in excess of 70 countries wherever English is one particular of the most important languages.

The worldwide diffusion of the language has now taken an exciting switch: the ratio among the native speakers of English (in international locations like the U.K., the United states, Canada, Australia and New Zealand) and the non-native speakers (in countries like India, Pakistan, Bangladesh, Singapore, Ghana, Kenya, Malaysia, Nigeria, Tanzania, Sri Lanka, Zambia, Philippines and many others exactly where English is applied alongside with the mother tongue) is virtually 40: 60, and it has expanded quickly to other international locations (like China, Japan, Egypt, Indonesia, Korea, Israel, Saudi Arabia, Zimbabwe, Taiwan, the Gulf Nations, and the international locations of the erstwhile Japanese Bloc). It is practically a indigenous language in South Africa, Jamaica and West Indies. Its acculturation, its global purposeful variety, and the varied sorts of literary creativeness it is accommodating are historically unprecedented.

As Braj B. Kachru notes, the circumstance today is these that the native speakers have an insignificant job in the world distribute and teaching of English they appear to have dropped the distinctive prerogative to handle its norms of use or standardization in truth, if present-day statistics are any sign, they have turn out to be a minority.

This sociolinguistic truth and its implications have not still been thoroughly acknowledged by most linguists, ELT practitioners, ESPists, directors, language plan planners, and faculty and university instructors in India. What we need to have now are new paradigms and views for linguistic and pedagogical exploration and for knowing the linguistic creativity, which includes the scientific and complex crafting, in multilingual circumstances throughout cultures.

You will respect the English we all talk is not like the English the indigenous speakers of the language discuss. We do not will need to. The yardsticks of the British or American native speakers, or their standards as mirrored in GRE, TOEFL or IELTS etc, or their variety of tongue twisting, are only detrimental to the pursuits of non-indigenous speakers. We have to develop our possess criteria, rather of teaching to sound like Londoners or North People in america. Pronunciation will have to be comprehensible and not detract from the understanding of a message. But for this no person needs to discuss the so referred to as standardized English that tends to make inter- and intranational communication difficult. David Crystal way too appreciates this reality and favours community flavor of English in India and elsewhere.

Our Indianness is evidently mirrored in the pronunciation of particular vowels and consonant, in the stressing of text, in the rhythm and pauses, in the vocabulary and lexical acculturation, discourse patterning, code mixing, usages, grammatical deviations and so forth. The extended linguistic and cultural get hold of of English in several states of the Indian union has specified it a one of a kind character which deserves critical tutorial exploration. It has obtained a appreciable useful array and depth, and it is preposterous to hope that the language would not be ‘shaped’ or ‘moulded’ in accordance to the neighborhood demands or stay unaffected by the influences of neighborhood languages and literatures, cultures and end users. It is, in reality, the outcome of these types of deep-rooted nearby capabilities, that we have now an institutionalized product of English for intranational makes use of. The way India’s multilingualism and ethnic pluralism have added to the complexity of Indian English, apart from ‘mixing’ terms, phrases, clauses and idioms from the Indian Language into English, and in ‘switching’ from a person language to yet another, most likely to express the speaker’s ‘identity’ or linguistic ‘belonging’, the purpose of ‘native speaker’– the British or American– as turn into peripheral, as Kachru rightly asserts, until he or she understands the nearby cultures and cultural presuppositions.

I am not extremely a great deal involved with the literary perspective of Indian English here, even if I have been actively affiliated with Indian English literary tactics for about thirty five a long time. I am professionally intrigued in the language use and utilization of Indian writers, and scholars and researchers of science and know-how, the localized educated wide range they have made to talk indigenous innovations. You can value this if you have discovered growth of neighborhood registers for agriculture, for the lawful method, for amusement field, for Setting, and so on. The publications of Indian practitioners of science and technology have specific discourse capabilities which are special to Indian English, but not examined.

I suspect Indian English is not nevertheless recognized as an critical area of study for ‘English for particular purposes’ (ESP) that we instruct. [It is also, however, very sad that though ESP as an approach is now firmly established, it still has fewer supporters in India, possibly because nobody wants any changes in the conventional teaching-learning practices?] Acquiring been in the forefront of ESP motion in the region for over twenty 5 years, I am aware of the localized linguistic innovations in the massive output of Indian scientists, some of which has the possible for serving correctly and successfully as pedagogical texts or instructing supplies. But it is unlucky the English teaching academia are slow to recognize the pragmatic contexts–the significance of intranational makes use of of English and in accordance to nearby requirements – and proceed to stick to the exterior norms of English. It really is much more regrettable that the conceptual and used investigation on ESP in the West has prevented addressing issues which are very important for knowing the use of English throughout cultures.

The way ESP has turned intercontinental, lecturers and researchers in Utilized Languages in our region need to discover: what accommodation a indigenous speaker of English could have to make for participation in interaction with these who use a regional (or non-native) selection of English what decides communicative performances or pragmatic success of English in its intercontinental takes advantage of what insights we have obtained by research on intelligibility and comprehensibility about international and intranational uses of English and what attitudinal and linguistic changes are desirable for successful teaching of ESP centered on a non-native English, like Indian English. These are a couple standard queries, not convenient to Western ESP fanatics.

I have seen in the Western ESP in typical, and science and technological know-how in individual, a robust bias towards ethno-centricism in strategy and neglect of intranational enthusiasm for the employs of English. It is not doable to exercise ESP effectively until we regard, what John Swales connect with, “area understanding” and “localized pragmatic demands”. After all, we use the language as a tool and we can not disregard the localized improvements that have “code-related” and “context-linked” dimensions. We ought to see non-native improvements in ESP as beneficial and contemplate them as aspect of the pragmatic requires of the people. It is the attitudinal improve that I plead for!

Teaching of ESP in a university in the next language scenario like ours is mostly a “collaborative feeling-building” with the class. When I say this, I am pointing to the interactive character of formal instruction, which, in terms of actual language use, is essentially Indian in tone, tenor and model. I am also referring to the want for comprehension the dichotomy among the rhetoric of EST training and the follow enacted in the classroom from the viewpoint of grownup learners, and language competencies progress and competence in the Indian social setting. We require to evolve a dynamic design of ‘communicative teaching’ of ESP which seeks to create (i)linguistic competence (Precision), (ii)pragmatic competence (Fluency), and (iii) sociolinguistic competence (Appropriacy), without ignoring interrelated elements of regional exercise, study and concept and at the very same time emphasizes language awareness, which is a major concept in ELT, in that it handles implicit, specific, and interactive awareness about language and offers for a vital awareness of language and literature techniques that are shaped by, and form, sociocultural associations, experienced marriage, and marriage of ability. The solution can also facilitate cross-cultural comparisons and contrasts, and endorse genre-based scientific studies (i.e. how language works to mean, how various strategies can be applied, how this means is manufactured), fundamental to ESP, in that it really develops individual’s general performance competence.

Mates, I have hopped from one particular level to yet another, potentially jumbled up, in my zeal to draw your awareness to several facets of English, Indian English and ESP that have broader and deeper implications. They touch attitudinal chords of English language end users, lecturers and administrators much too. Teaching of English, both equally language and literature, nowadays is not only academically hard but also opens new refreshing avenues for applied investigate. This is because of the unfold and transforming status of English, which has developed from a indigenous, second, and overseas language to come to be an worldwide language of commerce science and technological know-how, spoken amid extra non-natives than natives in the procedure of their skilled pursuits or each day life. I have also put particular information of science and engineering schooling in the context of Humanities right before you, elevated issues, expressed my check out, and now it is for the job to settle for, reject or discover their implications. Thank you.

Professor R.K.Singh
Head, Dept of Humanities & Social Sciences
Indian School of Mines
Dhanbad 826004 India

[This is the Text of my specially invited Lecture at SRM University’s International Conference on ‘Role and Responsibilities of Humanities and Social Sciences in Technical Education’ on 17 March 2011]

Articles You Might Like